I don’t read my replies

  • 4 Posts
  • 111 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: July 6th, 2023

help-circle


  • It’s not her fault.

    The Nazis, upon whom the empire borrows much, have an interesting management style. The theory was that leaders set goals and allowed subordinates a free hand in achieving these goals. Some of you may find that attractive, but there is a fatal catch. The subordinate is only “Free to Obey”, to achieve goals, never to set them. Even worse, responsibility is delegated with the tasks, so failure is the subordinates’ fault. It’s never a bad objective, scarce resources, or bad information; the people making the decisions are shielded from responsibility.

    Now back to Dedra. In her exit interview with Krennic, she explained how the ridged order and information control caused her to digg into places where she was not allowed, just to get the information she needed to pursue Axis. Nobody would have faulted her for arresting Luthin if he had survived.

    Had all of her misdeeds come to light under the auspices of success, she would have been praised for her cunning. She was constantly stymied and blocked by different organs of the Empire, set to cross purposes by pride, ambition, or stupidity. Decisions made by the likes of the Emporer or Director Krennic are what made Luthen’s long anonymity possible.

    Dedra didn’t doom the Death Star, she was on the verge of saving it. And she was fighting the Empire as much as the Rebellion.





  • He was still a one-man rebellion fighting for himself. It wasn’t until the funeral that he decided to throw his will to life into the furnace and give himself to rebellion.

    He made a decision on Fraxis to either die by Luthens hand or by the Emperor’s. The loss of Maarva made him so ashamed and angry that in the desire to make up for it, he made a suicide pact. That’s not the same man who jumped into the water and swam for his life.


  • If you remember the first season. Andor was a merc who did the Aldani job for payment. That’s why Luthin wanted to kill him; he wasn’t a rebel, but he had a head full of rebel intel.

    Maarva refused to go with him into his comfortable retirement and he basically abandoned her and the fight. He ran.

    His subsequent imprisonment was a direct result of him turning his back and choosing the easy path. He didn’t fail Maarva when she died, he failed her when he gave up the fight.

    EDIT: this is a big part of his development. He didn’t get radicalized in prison. He got radicalized by his guilt and grief for Maarva.